eSATA Hard Drive Pros and Cons

External SATA Drives Promise Portable Performance Benefits

Feb 8, 2009 Chad Criswell

Compared to USB, External SATA (eSATA) hard drives provide additional speed for high bandwidth applications. That performance comes at a slight premium in cost however.

While USB is the defacto standard for almost every commercially available external hard drive a new specification is starting to be incorporated into computer systems that promises increased speed and usability. External Serial ATA (eSATA) provides a direct channel to the computer's high performance Serial ATA bus, essentially allowing the external drive to operate and transfer information at speeds comparable to internally mounted SATA drives.

Benefits of eSATA Hard Drives

The primary reason to consider using an eSATA external hard drive is data transfer speed. Many people use external hard drives to store high bandwidth data such as video files. With standard USB connections (even with USB 2.0) transfer of large files or streaming video directly from the drive may be problematic due to the drive not being able to send the data through the USB pipe at a fast enough rate.

eSATA gets around this limitation by skipping the USB data channel and instead using the same channel that the computer's internal hard drives use. Data transfer rates can be twice as fast or more depending on the computer and the external storage device being used with a maximum throughput of 3gb/sec.

Any conventional SATA hard drive can be converted into an eSATA portable drive through the use of a special eSATA enclosure. These enclosures serve as portable cases for standard SATA hard drives

Flash memory can also benefit from the eSATA ports on newer computers. Products such as the Kanguru e-Flash are thumb drives that feature both USB and eSATA connections allowing the drive to be used with the high speed eSATA port or a standard USB port if no eSATA port is available.

Drawbacks to eSATA Hard Drives

The benefits of speed and flexibility provided by eSATA do come at a financial cost. Current eSATA hard drive enclosures sell for nearly double the cost of older style USB enclosures and require a separate power cable unlike some varieties of USB drive enclosures which can draw their power from the USB bus.

eSATA cables also max out at 2 meters compared to USB's 5 meters. Another consideration that a potential consumer must take into account is that eSATA is a fairly new technology that is not available in many computers.

Despite these minor downsides the higher performance and throughput of eSATA drives makes them increasingly attractive to anyone needing additional storage or a fast, effective backup solution. The slight premium in cost associated with the technology is offset by the benefits eSATA drives can provide.

The copyright of the article eSATA Hard Drive Pros and Cons in Computer Hardware/Accessories is owned by Chad Criswell. Permission to republish eSATA Hard Drive Pros and Cons in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.

The eSATA Logo

What do you think about this article?

---

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.

post your comment

What is 2+4?

Comments

Dec 10, 2009 4:34 AM

Guest :

concise and very helpful without being too technical. Just right.

Jan 9, 2010 9:36 AM

Guest :

Just the perfect information to help me create a "second hard drive" solution to a possible purchase of a laptop. Since I can't install a second internal hard disk drive, an eSATA drive is the perfect solution.

Jan 12, 2010 9:59 AM

Guest :

awesome.....this is y i like my lenovo y450 =] it comes with a eSATA port but i havent tried it yet cus the external hdd its kinda of expensive.
here a look for those looking for eSATA small hdds not the big types,
http://oyendigital.com/hard-drives/store/EN2-54-320-S.html
just very portable =]

Jan 14, 2010 9:35 AM

Guest :

FireWire 800 can provide good performance *for less
*, longer cables, more peripheral support, and you can connect up to 64 devices (like external HDD). In Write tests, FW800 matched eSATA, and did well in Read tests.
eSATA absolutely has its place, just consider your needs and budget before you choose.

4 Comments